News

LITIGATIONS

The Firm secures first-instance victory in litigation regarding the right to refund of the windfall profits tax unrelated to speculative energy price increases.

 

The Firm has secured a significant victory in first-instance litigation concerning the right to a refund of the portion of the "extraordinary contribution against rising energy costs"—the so-called 2022 windfall profits tax—not pertaining to speculative price increases in energy products. Represented by a team comprising Equity Partners Giuseppe Pizzonia and Marco Emma, acting on behalf of leading operators in the electricity sector, the Firm obtained recognition of the right to a refund for tax amounts related to "extraneous elements" before the Rome Tax Court of First Instance .

In Judgments Nos. 864 and 865 of 2026, the Court adopted a constitutionally oriented interpretation of the provision establishing the windfall profits tax, taking into account the legal arguments presented and the principles established by the Constitutional Court in Judgment No. 111/2024. Following the Constitutional Court’s determination that Article 37 of Decree-Law No. 21/2022 was partially unlawful in its inclusion of excise duties subsequently remitted to the State within the taxable base—calculated on the increase in periodic VAT settlement balances—the Rome Court held that other elements unrelated to the rationale of taxing speculative increases in energy sales prices must likewise be excluded. Specifically, the Court deemed it consistent with the legislative intent to exclude from the taxable base both the proceeds derived from the disposal of shareholdings and the revenues remitted to the GSE (Gestore dei Servizi Energetici) under the two-way compensation mechanism pursuant to Article 15-bis of Decree-Law No. 4/2022.

IlSole24Ore

February 11, 2026